
5 Stores Have The Best Meat In New York
If you're a meat-eater, your ears should be perking up! These 5 retailers that sell groceries in New York have been named among the highest quality meat departments in America. ChowHound put together a list of grocery stores with the highest quality meat counters.
Monthly, I put together a list of restaurants that do not pass their health code inspections. Eating food that is safe is super important. I have had to make it a point to cook more at home after seeing all of the recalls. But, even making food yourself can be dangerous too if you don't have high-quality ingredients.
READ MORE: 22 New York Roads You’ll Get An Automatic Speeding Ticket On
Wegmans
New Yorkers know that Wegmans is synonymous with quality. According to a survey by Consumers' Checkbook in Boston, the Delaware Valley, and the Washington D.C. area, Wegmans was among the highest-rated for meat quality. Wegmans sources its meat from local farms, giving shoppers fresher options. Tasting Table agrees with Chow Hound, ranking Wegmans at #2 on its "20 Popular Chain Grocery Stores For Meat, Ranked" list.
Costco
Of course, you have to be a member to shop Costco's meat department, but if you do have a membership, you are getting high-quality meat. Because Costco sells in bulk, you're looking at spending more, but you'll also be getting more. For example, Costco is offering 3 pounds of Japanese Wagyu Filet Mignons Steaks, A5 Grade, for $649.99.
Whole Foods
Whole Foods offers customers a wide variety of meat options. Whole Foods offers a 12-month apprenticeship for team members who want to learn to become butchers. Whole Foods offers local animal welfare-certified, organic, and grass-fed meat choices, including dry-aged steaks, house-made sausages, and air-chilled chicken.
The Fresh Market
While The Fresh Market made the list, there are only four locations in New York - Latham, Saratoga Springs, Scarsdale, and Smithtown. It offers beef that is aged two weeks to make it more tenders, beef ground daily, which is to be sold only on the same day it was sold, and antibiotic-free poultry.
BJ's Wholesale Club
According to Chow Hound,
"The company offers a wide selection, including grass-fed beef, free-range chicken, and antibiotic-free products. Much of the company's meat is from its private label, Wellsley Farms, and overall, the steaks from the store get rave reviews online (the ribeyes are mentioned in multiple sources as one of the better items)."
You can view all the stores with the highest quality meat departments here.

Top 10 Most Popular Grocery Stores In New York State 2025
Gallery Credit: Karolyi