Best Pizza In Western New York

Buffalo is known for its wings, but there are amazing places for all types of food around Western New York, including pizza.

Best Pizza In Buffalo, New York

You can ask a thousand people where the best pizza is, and you might get a thousand different answers. If you were to ask my wife, Elizabeth, she would tell you there is only one place to go, that is My Tomato Pie on Niagara Falls Boulevard in Amherst, New York.

We just went there on Sunday for the first time ever and wanted to try one of their most popular pizzas. One that has been on the menu from Day 1 and one that people love to order and order again. It is their Cheese Steak Pizza. It comes with a white sauce, topped with mozzarella, fontina, cheddar,jack, and romano cheese. It is also covered in hot banana peppers, fried onions, and a special sauce. I love how they layer the cheeses over the ingridents which keeps them nice and toasty without drying them out.

The dough is also made fresh daily, which helps make this pizza the best in the 716.

Photo Credit: Dave Fields/TSM2026

If cheese steak pizza is not your cup of tea, they have 16 different specialty pizzas, along with a thousand different creations when you build your own.

If you are not looking for pizza, My Tomato Pie is still worth a visit. They have a massive menu that ranges from Chicken Parm to burgers to Lobster Ravioli. Even the salads they offer will delight your taste buds.

Save Money At My Tomato Pie With Our "We Are Buffalo" Deal

The best part is that you can try out My Tomato Pie and save some money this week. They are our "We ARe Buffalo" deal of the week, and you can score a $50 gift card for only $25.

You can get this deal HERE or using our APP.